Is Qatar's national vision blurred?
Maybe one day Qatar will regret December 10, 2012, the day when it was appointed host for the 2022 FIFA World Cup. Ever since, Qatar has been in the spotlight. How did this tiny country become the organizer of a sport event as big as the football world cup? Is it possible at all to play football in Qatar, in the desert, in the heat? Who will build the new stadiums that Qatar needs for the games? Migrant workers from Nepal, Pakistan and India, we hear. Are they well paid, well protected and respected?
Much has been published about Qatar since that day. However, most of the information that the media has given to an uninformed audience in Europe and the United States was wrong.
“How come the press is reporting about migrant workers being abused, even killed, when constructing the new football stadiums?” Robert, a diplomat serving in Qatar, asked me when I talked to him while visiting the country at the end of March 2014. “The construction hasn't even started yet.”
“But there is no question about it,” Robert continued, “the migrant workers are really badly treated here.”
For its future, Qatar has a plan. Organizing the world cup is just one of the milestones, albeit a big one, aimed at gaining recognition outside Qatar's usual comfort zones. Qatar is well known inside the diplomatic circles in the Middle East and at investors' meetings in Germany and France. Now Qatar wants to please to the common people.
Qatar's plan is called the Qatar National Vision 2030, QNV 2030 in short. It formulates a strategy for development and sets goals that the country intends to reach in less than two decades. Let me walk you through the QNV 2030 and point out some observations that crossed my mind when reading the document after my visit to Qatar.
“Qatar is at a crossroads,” the paper starts. “The country's abundant wealth creates both opportunities and challenges. It is now imperative for Qatar to choose the best development path that is compatible with the views of its leadership and the aspirations of its people.”
The leadership of Qatar has views, the people have (just) aspirations: what if they don't match? Is there a political process – democratic, if possible – to make sure that the aspirations of the people become the views of the leadership?
Qatar's national vision rests on four pillars: human development, social and economic development, and environmental development. And what about political development, the critical observer is tempted to ask? Does the Qatari government, the authors of QNV 2030, foresee a broader political participation in 2030? The question is carefully avoided throughout the entire well-crafted document.
If Qatar wants to build a stable society that will weather the storms that surely will lay ahead, a strong civil society is a must. “Centrality is not the opposite of anarchy; civil society is,” Robert D. Kaplan stated in a recent article for Stratfor. The success and the failures of the so-called Arab Spring in Tunisia, Egypt and Libya certainly prove this point right.
Other questions that are conspicuously bypassed in QNV 2030 are the tough issues regarding the foreign workers. The paper only talks in very general terms about “the size and the quality of the expatriate labor force,” as if this was merely a question of management.
But who in Qatar cares about the labor force's working conditions?Does QNV 2030, and particularly the human development part, also apply to foreigners in air conditioned offices, migrant workers on construction sites and domestic workers? They constitute 85% of the people living on the peninsula!
An Amnesty International report published in April 2014 that was entitled “my sleep is my break” harshly criticized the conditions under which domestic workers live and work in Qatar. They suffer from extreme working hours and a lack of rest days, which can lead to seven-day, 100-hour working weeks. Their freedom of movement is restricted and they are often verbally harassed and physically and sexually mistreated.
- Qatar National Research Strategy Forum praises industry partners for collaborating to tackle key issues in line with the Qatar National Vision 2030
- Let the games--err, the building for the games--begin! Qatar commences work on FIFA stadiums
- Qatar Foundation Generates Solar Energy to Support Qatar National Vision And Strengthens Sustainability Efforts With New Energy Monitoring Centre
- National Vision meets World Cup: Qatar's active projects at $285 billion
- pata: don't let freak weather conditions become more common