U.S. Israeli lobby accuses Iran of sabotaging nuclear talks
U.S. Senator Robert Menendez, chairman of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, expressed deep skepticism on Sunday that world powers will be able to forge a comprehensive agreement with Iran on its nuclear program.
The New Jersey Democrat and Senate foreign policy chief placed blame for those odds squarely on an "obfuscating" Iran— and on the international community for wanting "any deal" on the nuclear crisis "more than a good deal," he said.
"If past is prologue, I’m skeptical of Iran keeping its promises," Menendez (D-NJ) said. "Based on the parameters described in the Joint Plan of Action, all I have heard in briefings, and recent Iranian actions— I am very concerned."
Speaking to The Jerusalem Post Annual Conference in New York on Sunday, Menendez issued his support for US President Barack Obama's efforts to forge a lasting nuclear agreement— what Obama has called one of the two greatest foreign policy goals of his presidency, alongside the achievement of a peace accord between Israel and the Palestinians.
But Menendez, a veteran of the upper chamber who has worked on Iran policy for decades, is also the author of the latest sanctions bill against Iran that would have triggered new financial penalties against the Islamic Republic if negotiations expired this summer without a final deal.
Obama threatened to veto that bill in January, warning that its passage might fray the international consensus at the negotiating table amongst the P5+1— the US, United Kingdom, France, China, Russia and Germany— across from Iran.
Menendez defended the bill once again on Sunday. But he stopped short of renewing his call for a swift vote in the Senate. The bill has 59 cosponsors, but is unlikely to reach the floor for debate.
"Make no mistake," Menendez said: "While they are smiling at our negotiators across the table, they are plotting in the back room."
His harsh words on Iran extended beyond its nuclear program: "Iran-like fundamentalist theocracies bent on turning the clock back 500 years," he said, should be "relegated to the dustbin" of history.
Negotiations between the P5+1 and Iran resume this week in Vienna.
Menendez, a Democrat, made a broad case for "conservative" policies on Israel and on the policy priorities shared between Israel and the United States.
That conservatism, according to Menendez, extends across party lines in Washington— most definitively on the issue of Israel's character as the Jewish homeland.
"We are all conservative when it comes to Israel’s right to exist as a Jewish state," Menendez said. "We are all conservative when it comes to keeping the people of Israel safe and secure in their homes and within their borders."
Menendez last spoke extensively on Iran and the Middle East peace process at the American Israel Public Affairs Committee, where he opened for Prime Minister Benyamin Netanyahu.
The senator quoted Netanyahu's AIPAC speech on Sunday, where the Israeli premiere said there can be 'no fantasy of flooding Israel with refugees," and "no movement to amputate parts of the Negev and the Galilee.'"
"Notwithstanding any hopes we may harbor, one thing is certain, set in stone: President Abbas must recognize the Jewish state as a Jewish state without equivocation," Menendez charged, questioning whether the Palestinian Authority was a "committed partner" in the peace process.
Since taking over from John Kerry— who left his foreign relations chairmanship in the Senate to succeed Hillary Clinton as secretary of state— Menendez has put threats emanating from Syria and Iran front and center on Capitol Hill.
While Menendez holds the respect of the Obama administration, the senator is keen on proving the worth of the Senate on foreign policy, and considers the legislature an equal branch of government on affairs abroad.
Menendez underlined that message in his Sunday address. He repeatedly backed Obama's approach to Iran, and reinforced his support for the president's performance on Syria throughout the chemical weapons crisis that gripped the world last August. But he also took credit for the results of that policy: Bashar Assad's signing of the Chemical Weapons Convention, and his agreeing to rid Syria of its massive stockpiles of chemical arms.
"On Syria, my Committee’s authorization for the use of military force last September was the reason— and the only reason, I am convinced— Assad agreed to dismantle and destroy his regime’s arsenal of chemical weapons," Menendez said. "Our willingness to use our military power can be a force for positive change."
Menendez spoke to a crowd of over 1,000 at the third Jerusalem Post Annual Conference in Times Square in New York City.
- 36 years, one conversation: The history of the Iran nuclear talks
- Being Jewish didn’t stop this US senator from supporting the Iran deal
- US insists nuclear talks are secure following accusations of Israeli cyber spying
- Chairman of Iran’s Parliamentary Foreign Affairs Committee: Secret US-Iran talks took place
- Iran arrests four over nuclear sabotage plot