Bahraini players’ support for Sheikh Salman raises more questions than answers
Sheikh Salman Bin Ebrahim Al-Khalifa
In recent statements, Bahraini football players sought to absolve Asian Football Confederation (AFC) president and world football body FIFA presidential candidate Sheikh Salman Bin Ebrahim Al-Khalifa, who is a member of Bahrain’s ruling family, of any moral or direct responsibility for the arrest, dismissal, and abuse of hundreds of sports executives and athletes accused of protesting against repressive and discriminatory rule.
The statements, including one by Bahrain’s top player Alaa Hubail, who was publicly humiliated on national television in what amounted to a kangaroo court with the acquiescence of the Gulf state’s top sports executive and has alleged that he was tortured while under arrest in 2011, came as human rights activists unsuccessfully demanded that FIFA disqualify Sheikh Salman, who at the time was head of the Bahrain Football Association (BFA).
The statements, made in a series of interviews with Inside World Football, raise more questions than answers to the long-standing allegations against Sheikh Salman. He consistently denied personal involvement but repeatedly stopped short of refuting underlying facts. His statements appeared to be carefully crafted to ensure that FIFA’s ethics committee would have no grounds to disqualify his candidacy, which was approved earlier this week.
The usually tight-lipped Bahraini national, recently acknowledged in his most detailed response government plans in 2011 to establish a committee that would identify sports executives and athletes opposed to the government and single them out for punishment. Asserting that the committee was never constituted, Sheikh Salman stopped short of denying reports by the Bahrain News Agency (BNA), the government’s official mouthpiece, that he would be head of committee.
Sheikh Salman also never denied BNA reports quoting heads of sports associations, including his own BFA secretary general at the time, Abdulrahman Al Sayer, that they were taking actions against executives and athletes. In the words of Al-Sayer, anyone who violates the law “through participation in marches or gatherings illegal, or anything else (that) was intended to ‘attempt to overthrow the regime or offending national codes’” will be punished.
Hubail and his brother Mohammed, who also played for Bahrain’s national team, were only released from prison after FIFA pressured the government on their behalf. Four other national team players were detained at the same time.
In his endorsement of Sheikh Salman’s FIFA candidacy, Hubail did not retract his earlier assertions that he was arrested and tortured in 2011. Speaking to Inside World Football, Hubail charged that the media had portrayed him as a traitor. It was not clear whether this was a reference to a talk show broadcast on state-run television in April 2011 in, which Hubail participated and was accused by the show host of treason for participating in an anti-government protest during a popular revolt.
Sheikh Salman’s then-superior, Prince Nasser bin Hamad Al-Khalifa, son of King Hamad bin Isa bin Salman Al-Khalifa, commander of Bahrain’s Royal Guard, head of its National Olympic Committee, and the official who decreed establishment of the committee the AFC president was supposed to head, phoned in to the show at the time, to congratulate the hosts and reinforce their message.
“Well done, guys. And on your efforts, all of you. And to everyone who stood and proved his loyalty to the Kingdom of Bahrain, leadership and people. And anyone who called for the fall of the regime, may a wall fall on his head… People have involved themselves in matters and have lost the love of their fans. People have entered labyrinths in which they will be lost… Anyone who involved himself in these matters and was part of it will be held accountable. Whether he is an athlete, socialite or politician, whatever he is — he will now be held accountable. Today is judgment day. May God grant patience and strength to all. Bahrain is an island and there is nowhere to escape… It is known who stood against us. The days will judge,” Prince Nasser said.
Neither Hubail, who largely remained silent since speaking out about his ordeal four and a half years ago, nor Inside World Football explained what had persuaded the player to break his silence and endorse Sheikh Salman.
Hubail told the sports publication he hoped “Shaikh Salman becomes (FIFA) president because he would be the first Arab president and that makes me very proud”. He denied the allegations against Sheikh Salman.
“I know Salman and have travelled several times with him. I have known him a long time. It is not in his character to do anything like this. It is unfair to say that. Sheikh Salman was not involved in the political decisions. They [media and human rights organisations] are using 2011 because he is part of the [Bahraini] royal family. I want to be completely honest. I have not encountered anything to believe these allegations are true,” Hubail said. Al-Oraibi was playing a match in Qatar when he was sentenced; he never returned to Bahrain.
Hubail’s remarks were echoed by two other players, Sayed Adnan and goalkeeper Ali Saeed, who were also detained in 2011 and who, like Hubail, have remained silent in recent years. Like in the case of Hubail, it was not clear why Saeed and Adnan, who briefly fled to Australia, decided to break their silence.
Adnan told Inside World Football that he was “absolutely” sure that the allegations against Sheikh Salman were false and that torture had not occurred. Adnan’s remarks contradicted an independent government-endorsed inquiry in 2011 that concluded that torture of some of those arrested in the wake of the 2011 revolt had occurred. The report’s conclusions made no specific reference to athletes or sports executives. “I have been in Australia but did not hear one person that said he [Salman] did all these things,” Adnan said.
Adnan’s remarks also contrasted starkly with statements he made in Australia four years ago when he asserted that “my colleagues were tortured to say that I organized the march just like what happened with Ali Saeed. A high-level officer sent me a message by way of the released detainees to return to Bahrain. “He said that I could return and they would not touch me. If they have nothing to do with me, then why were my colleagues tortured and why were the authorities asking them about me?” Adnan said, distrustful of Bahraini authorities.
Saaed asked, “Why now?” ignoring the fact that controversy over Sheikh Salman’s human rights record has repeatedly surfaced since 2011.
“He [Sheikh Salman] will be number one in the world if he comes to FIFA so nobody will be over him – they will not let him take it easy. They will look to find others [for the presidency] but tell me, who is really the good man? I am happy that Prince Ali of Lebanon is a candidate. But I wish the best for Sheikh Salman because he is from my country. I will be proud if he cuts it. It is an honour for us if he is the one [president] of FIFA,” Saeed said, getting his facts wrong since Prince Ali is a brother of King Abdullah of Jordan.
Former Bahrain national team and Al-Shabab SC player Hakeem Al-Oraibi and his family repeatedly asked the BFA, during Sheikh Salman’s reign, to intervene in the two instances in which the player was arrested. Al-Oraibi, speaking from Australia where he plays for Green Gully SC, said the BFA promised to help but never did.
Al-Oraibi was held for six months in 2010, during which he claims he was repeatedly beaten on his legs because he was a player before being released without charge. Two years later, he was again detained for three months and regularly beaten then released on bail but charged with setting a police station on fire. Al-Oraibi was ultimately sentenced to 10 years in prison despite his ability to prove that he could be seen at the moment of the attack because he was playing in a televised soccer match.
“My family talked to the BFA. They gave them documentation. The documentation was given to Salman but he didn’t do anything,” Al-Oraibi said. The BFA told his family they “would see what they could do”.
“They mentioned Sheikh Salman by name. They never came back to them… The BFA knew I was playing live on television. The BFA should have advised the police of this. Especially since I have been playing for the national team since I was a kid… They should have cared,” he said.
The police officers who beat Al-Oraibi probably cared little about Bahraini football. Al-Oraibi said they were Pakistani, Yemeni and Jordanian nationals.
That, however, should have been a concern for Sheikh Salman, even if had no direct leverage over Bahrain’s security forces and judiciary. Al-Oraibi was playing a match in Qatar when he was sentenced. He never returned to Bahrain.
The FIFA presidential candidate never spoke out about what was an apparent miscarriage of justice in the case of Al-Oraibi as he never did about the ordeal of Hubail and other players. All of which begs the question, why players are suddenly rallying around a man, who at the very least never truly stood up for them.
James M. Dorsey is a senior fellow at the S. Rajaratnam School of International Studies, co-director of the University of Würzburg’s Institute for Fan Culture, and the author of The Turbulent World of Middle East Soccer blog and a forthcoming book with the same title.
- Shaikh Salman vows to lift FIFA from 'ashes'
- Tokyo Olympic organizers deny alleged payment for support
- Business meets politics: Germany’s arms exports to Egypt, Saudi Arabia and UAE raise 'harrowing questions'
- Pressure builds on Sheikh Salman to respond to human rights allegations
- Winning Georgetown University student beats out the competition at ARC 2014