Bridging differences between the West and the Muslim world: seeing past religion and through culture

Bridging differences between the West and the Muslim world: seeing past religion and through culture
4.00 6

Published May 25th, 2013 - 05:00 GMT via

Rate Article:

PRINT Send Mail
comment (2)
One among too many who have turned ignorance into hatred, Islamophobic Anders Behring Breivik killed over 70 people through terror attacks in 2011 in Norway.
One among too many who have turned ignorance into hatred, Islamophobic Anders Behring Breivik killed over 70 people through terror attacks in 2011 in Norway.
More >
Washington, D.C.
Timothy McVeigh
Akbar Ahmed
Salman Rushdie
Anti-Defamation League
Federal Bureau of Investigation
Cambridge University
Georgetown University’s Berkley Center for Religion, Peace and World Affairs
Islamic Society of North America
White House
Public Religion Research Institute

From the time Salman Rushdie’s “The Satanic Verses” was published over two decades ago, when I was at Cambridge University, I have been fully involved in promoting dialogue and understanding between the West and the Muslim world.

I have met with great minds at the White House, Pentagon and the Federal Bureau of Investigation, and spoken with rabbis, priests and imams, only to find that, despite countless hours spent as a goodwill ambassador among civilizations, there is a persistent, divisive misunderstanding between Muslims and the West, and it manifests itself in tragic displays of violence.

Post-9/11 thinking has conflated religion and culture in the Muslim world, branded it as dangerous, transformed the mosaic of Islam into a monolith and pitted it against the globalized West, which is seen as modern, decadent and secular. These conceptions are both inherently flawed and worryingly reductionist. As a bridge between cultures, worldviews and religions, Muslim-Western relations, which seeks to unpack and decode each culture for the other, has much to offer.

Indeed, anyone questioning whether the field of Muslim-Western relations is still relevant has only to look at current – and unfortunate – events in American and international news.

In the U.S., fear and anger from the tragedy at the Boston marathon has been directed toward innocent Muslims by their fellow Americans, who are confused and upset by the death and destruction visited upon runners and spectators. Some have mistakenly lumped all Muslims together into one threatening, homogeneous group. We have even seen senseless acts of violence directed at Sikhs, who fit a stereotypical – and inaccurate – profile, which holds that all Muslims are bearded and wear turbans.

I have found that ultimately it is ignorance, a lack of compassion, a feeling of helplessness and misplaced rage that drives individuals to lash out at each other and commit acts of aggression.

A gap exists between Muslims and the West, demonstrated to shocking effect by a study compiled by Georgetown University’s Berkley Center for Religion, Peace and World Affairs in April 2012. A full 47 percent of those between 18 and 24, questioned on whether Islam was at odds with American values, answered in the affirmative. Similarly, the Public Religion Research Institute’s 2013 survey on religion, values and immigration reform found that 47 percent of people asked this exact question agreed that Muslim values were contrary to the American way of life.

In light of these findings, the necessity for interfaith understanding is even more urgent. It is more difficult to hate – even dislike – people when you have met them, shared a meal or a cup of tea, listened to their stories and allowed yourself to recognize them as human.

Like me, my friends at the National Cathedral in Washington, D.C., have demonstrated admirable support for interfaith dialogue through endeavors such as the Sunday Forum, where intellectuals of all faiths explore the roots of religious intolerance, building a pluralistic future for our children, and fostering understanding among all faiths.

The Anti-Defamation League, a predominately Jewish organization, is also committed to protecting fellow Americans, including Muslims. They condemn the spread of hate literature about Muslims, attacks on mosques and legal campaigns that would limit the ability of American Muslims to freely practice their religion. Similarly, the Islamic Society of North America collaborates with both Christian and Jewish organizations to promote tolerance and cooperation among faiths.

While some Islamophobic individuals turn to scripture to shore up their claims that Islam and Western values are destined to be at odds with each other, I would charge them to look past the fragments of information they collect to thoroughly examine the entire tapestry of Islam – a religion whose very definition means peace. I would remind them that just as Timothy McVeigh did not represent Christianity, neither does Tamerlan Tsarnaev represent Islam.

Labeling each other as monolithic, static cultures has yielded nothing positive. Misunderstanding leads to negative consequences, whether in daily communication or on a global, political scale. It is only by adopting the wisdom of Harper Lee’s immortal character, Atticus Finch, that we will achieve clarity: “You never really understand a person until you consider things from his point of view – until you climb into his skin and walk around in it.”

By Akbar Ahmed.


Copyright © 2013, The Daily Star. All rights reserved.

Very nice article. However, the fear and developing hatred towards Muslims is understandable when one's looking at current events. It is not to say it is justified but only understandable.
Had the Muslim leadership taken a much stronger stand against radicalism in the Muslim faith, "westerners" might have felt that the radical movement is indeed a minority. however, since that criticism within the Muslim world are few and quite there is a maybe unjustified but still getting stronger a feeling that the radical Islam is the main force within the Muslim world. Until the Muslim leadership will not take a strong stand against bodies that are involved in terrorism like Iran, Hezbollah, and other radical imams (Egypt anyone), the Muslims will keep on suffering from this development in Islamophobia .

Dorian Black (not verified) Sat, 05/25/2013 - 13:01

akbar ahmed ignores the origins of Islam in desert robbery and nomadic living, that sees rural civilization as decadent
and idolizes power and the kind of justice that says, when I am hungry and you have food, you must give it to me or I will kill you. and because hunger is a permanent condition for hunter gatherers without long term planning, they are permanently angry and hostile to civilization.That's the basis of Islam and of living like Mohamed.

Anonymous (not verified) Sat, 05/25/2013 - 09:32

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.