Laws under a caliphate are traditionally defined in accordance with Islamic ethics. In the past the role of caliph has largely been symbolic, leaving the day-to-day running of government down to the devolved powers of local rulers.
The last widely-acknowledged caliphate was under the Ottoman Empire, which used the symbolic power of its caliph to rule across vast reaches of the Arabic world. The caliphate in this sense ended with the establishment of the Turkish Republic in 1923, though the Ahmadiyya Muslim Community has defined its leader as the “caliph” since the early 20th century.
IS’s claim to have restored the caliphate represents a huge challenge to other Islamist and al-Qaeda-affiliated groups in the region, explains Charlie Cooper, a researcher for the Quilliam counter-extremism think-tank.
He told The Independent: “The fact that Isis has done this has huge ideological and theological implications and it is a big challenge to al-Qaeda, their spokespeople may well try to reclaim their legitimacy.
“There will be a lot of criticism from people saying announcing the restoration of the caliphate is premature, but Isis have rapidly evolved over the past few years and there’s now a cult of personality about Baghdadi in Arabic social media.
“He is a very popular figure, and this will make people from al-Qaeda and other groups question whether they should really be fighting for him.”
In the latest example of Isis’ sophisticated use of social media, Cooper said a new propaganda video released 15 minutes before the announcement included a “hint” towards what was about to come, with a Chilean foreign fighter describing Baghdadi as his “Caliph”.
“Everything that Isis has done has been very tactical with meticulous in planning,” he said.
By Adam Withnall