White House: Biden and Jinping Are Not Old Friends

Published November 17th, 2021 - 11:09 GMT
White House insists Biden, China's Xi aren't 'old friends'
President Biden met with his Chinese counterpart to discuss bilateral issues. Alex Wong/Getty Images/AFP
White House Deputy Press Secretary Andrew Bates insisted that President Joe Biden does not consider Chinese President Xi Jinping a friend

White House officials insisted on Tuesday that President Joe Biden does not consider China's President Xi Jinping an 'old friend' after an interpreter said as much during their virtual meeting on Monday. 

'You've heard explicitly from the president himself, that he has a longstanding relationship with President Xi,' said White House Deputy Press Secretary Andrew Bates on Tuesday.  

'They've spent a great deal of time together. They are able to have candid discussions, be direct with each other, which helps them be productive. 

'But he does not consider President Xi an old friend,' Bates told reporters. 

Xi appeared to troll Biden by greeting him as an 'old friend' at the meeting - in direct contradiction to repeated denials from both the president and Press Secretary Jen Psaki. 

In response, Biden, who has previously pushed back on the assertion he and Xi were friends and called their meetings 'pure business', suggested that they should start the meeting 'more formally, even though you and I have never been that formal.'

Over the summer, Biden responded sharply to Fox News White House correspondent Peter Doocy, who asked if he would call Xi 'old friend to old friend' - seeking access for World Health Organization investigators searching for the origins of COVID-19.

'Let's get something straight,' Biden replied in June during a press conference in Switzerland. 'We know each other well. We're not old friends. It's just pure business.' 

And before Monday's virtual meeting took place, Press Secretary Jenn Psaki clarified that Biden was by no means close friends with Xi, but said the leaders' level of rapport would allow them to have 'candid discussions.' 

'Well...I can confirm...he still does not consider him an 'old friend,' so that remains consistent,' Psaki said ahead of the meeting between the two world leaders. 

The Chinese leader originally used the expression 'lao peng you,' which connotes fondness and shows a level of familiarity and trust, following months of tension between the US and China. 

Said by Xi, 68, the expression reflects a shared history that dates to August 2011, when he and Biden held hours of conversations and traveled in Sichuan province - when Xi was First secretary of the Communist Party and Biden was Vice President under Obama.  

Wang Huiyao, president of the Center for China and Globalization, said Xi's use of the expression is a show of genuine goodwill.  

During the virtual meeting on Monday night, Biden shared that he and Xi have 'always communicated with one another very honestly and candidly' and they 'never walk away wondering what the other man is thinking.' 

Daniel Russel, the top US diplomat for Asia under former President Barack Obama, said it was part of each leader's seeking the 'narrative high ground' at the opening.

'Xi deliberately greeting Biden as 'my old friend' - after Biden went on record this summer expressly denying that they are 'friends.' And Biden, with a toothy smile, reminding Xi that all countries - including China - 'have to play by the same rules of the road',' Russel said.

Shi Yinhong, professor of international relations at Renmin University of China, noted Xi's use of the term despite the difficult state of relations.

'When we Chinese call someone an old friend, we mean we've known him for a long time. But an 'old friend' doesn't necessarily mean he is still a real friend,' Shi said.

Given current diplomatic tensions, Biden may not want to be seen by US allies and his political opponents as too much of a 'friend'.  

The United States and China disagree on the origins of the COVID-19 pandemic, trade and competition rules, Beijing's expanding nuclear arsenal and its stepped-up pressure on Taiwan, among other issues. 

Biden promised to address areas of concern, including human rights and other issues in the Indo-Pacific region.

He told the Chinese leader he was looking forward to a 'candid and forthright discussion,' which will ensure 'simple, straightforward competition' between China and the United States.  

'We need to establish some common-sense guardrails,' Biden said, adding, 'especially on vital global issues like climate change.' 

The meeting went 'longer than expected' a senior administration official said on a call with reporters after midnight. It lasted for about three and a half hours, broken into two sessions.   

'The conversation was respectful and straight-forward and open,' the official said. 'They didn't just stick to the scripts in front of them.' 

Chinese officials said in advance that Taiwan would be their top issue for the talks.

Tensions have heightened as the Chinese military has dispatched an increasing number of fighter jets near the self-ruled island of Taiwan, which Beijing considers part of its territory.   

'The Taiwan issue concerns China's sovereignty and territorial integrity, as well as China's core interest,' Chinese Foreign Ministry spokesperson Zhao Lijian said Monday. 'It is the most important and sensitive issue in China-U.S. relations.' 

On the video call, Biden reiterated the U.S. will abide by the longstanding U.S. 'One China' policy, which recognizes Beijing but allows informal relations and defense ties with Taipei. 

The statement reiterated longstanding US policy that does not recognize Taiwan's independence but allows informal and defense ties with Taipei. 

According to the US official, who asked not to be identified, there was 'extended discussion of Taiwan' during the summit.  

Tension over Taiwan in particular is threatening to escalate into dangerous new territory.

China has ramped up military activities near Taiwan in recent years, with a record number of warplanes intruding into the island's air defense zone in October.

The United States says it supports Taiwan's self-defense but is ambiguous about whether it would intervene to help directly.

In the brief comments made in front of reporters, Xi referred to each country needing to 'run our domestic affairs' but did not mention US criticism of Beijing's saber-rattling around Taiwan, mass human rights violations or other sore points.

Next year's Beijing Olympics didn't come up. 

There have been some calls for the U.S. to boycott the Winter Olympic Games over China's human rights abuses.  

Biden did talk to Xi about human rights, the senior official confirmed. 

'The two leaders have had many discussions about human rights issues over the years and they've talked about it at some length,' the official said. 'It's no secret that they have a real difference in world views.'  

Biden was 'quite clear and quite candid' when talking to Xi about human rights, and spent time speaking about Xinjiang, Tibet, and Hong Kong, as well as human rights more broadly, a White House readout said.  

'We were not expecting a breakthrough, there were none to report,' the official said more generally about the call. 

The White House said that the two leaders also talked about Iran, Afghanistan and North Korea. 

They also talked about the U.S.-China trade deal, with Biden pushing for China to fulfill its phase one commitments. 

The senior administration official wouldn't say if Biden and Xi talked about China's hypersonic missiles - though hinted that the president asked China to be more transparent as the world seeks answers about the origins of COVID-19.

The president 'also talked about the importance of preventing future pandemics and the important role that transparency plays in addressing global health issues,' the official said.  

At the top of the meeting, Biden told Xi, 'We have a responsibility to the world as well as to our people.' 

'That's why we believe – and you and I have talked about this – all countries have to play by the same rules of the road, why the United States is always going to stand up for our interests and values, and those of our allies and partners,' Biden said. ''If past is prologue, I am sure that today we'll be discussing those areas where we have concerns – on human rights, on economics, to ensuring a free and open Indo Pacific.'

Biden also shared that he and Xi have 'always communicated with one another very honestly and candidly.' 

'We never walk away wondering what the other man is thinking,' Biden said. 

Before turning the program over to Xi, Biden thanked the Chinese leader for calling and congratulating him after he won the election last year, saying it was 'very gracious.' 

Through a translator, Xi told Biden, 'Good to see you, Mr. President and your colleagues.' 

'It's the first time for us to meet virtually, although it's not as good as a face to face meeting, I'm very happy to see my old friend,' Xi said.   

'Humanity lives in a global village, and we face multiple challenges together,' Xi said. 'China and the U.S. need to increase communication and cooperation,' the Chinese president also offered. 

The two men were meeting Monday night Washington time, while it's already Tuesday morning in Beijing.  

The aim of Monday's virtual summit with China is to defuse tensions over Taiwan and other flashpoints. 

However, both sides have signaled little appetite for compromise.   

'Certainly, the president will express areas where he feels China should be taking additional action, should be behaving in a different manner that is more aligned with the rules of the road and the expectations with the United States and the global community,' Psaki said. 

The two leaders have spoken by phone twice since Biden's inauguration in January but with Xi refusing to travel abroad because of the pandemic, an online video meeting is the only option short of an in-person summit.

Most attention in the build-up has focused on the sparring over Taiwan, a self-ruling democracy claimed by China, and Biden's aides have cast the summit as an opportunity to help prevent tensions escalating.

'We know as a responsible global leader that it's important to keep channels of communication open,' a senior administration official told reporters, adding that competition between the two countries should not lead to conflict.

'The president will also make clear that we want to build common guardrails to avoid miscalculation or misunderstanding.'

At the same time, the White House sought to temper expectations, with the official saying that the summit 'is not a meeting where we expect deliverables to be coming out.'

Biden, a veteran of foreign policy issues during his decades in politics, has often said phone conversations are no substitute for face-to-face meetings.

Xi has not left China for nearly two years, and Biden sharply criticised his absence at the recent COP-26 climate summit in Glasgow and G20 summit in Rome.

Relations between the superpowers plummeted during the presidency of Donald Trump, who launched a trade war with China while assailing Beijing over its handling of the pandemic.

Biden has recast the confrontation more broadly as a struggle between democracy and autocracy. 

And while the day-to-day tone is more measured than under Trump, relations have worsened over Taiwan.

China has ramped up military activities near Taiwan in recent years, with a record number of warplanes intruding into the island's air defense zone in October.

The United States says it supports Taiwan's self-defense but is ambiguous about whether it would intervene to help directly. China is stepping up its rhetoric, warning Washington to keep out.

'Any connivance of and support for the 'Taiwan independence' forces undermines peace across the Taiwan Strait and would only boomerang in the end,' Chinese Foreign Minister Wang Yi told US Secretary of State Antony Blinken in a weekend meeting.

China's foreign ministry on Monday put the onus on Biden to improve relations.

'We hope that the U.S. will work in the same direction as China to get along with each other,' foreign ministry spokesman Zhao Lijian told reporters.

Chinese state media on Monday also portrayed Taiwan as the key flashpoint in current US-China tensions.

The United States must 'take a step back from the Taiwan question,' the Global Times, a hawkish tabloid, said in an editorial.

However the US administration official signaled Biden would be 'very direct' on what he called 'China's coercive and provocative behavior with respect to Taiwan.'

The official also stressed that the two nations had room for cooperation in various areas, such as climate change.

This virtual meeting is being held at a time when Xi continues to strengthen his grip on power.

Top Chinese Communist Party leaders last week passed a resolution that is expected to help Xi shore up his power by setting in stone his vision for China and diminishing the role of previous leaders.

The resolution 'further cemented' power in the hands of the Chinese president, the Washington official said.

The official added, 'In our mind that just further underscores the importance of this leader level engagement.'

This article has been adapted from its original source.

© Associated Newspapers Ltd.

You may also like