A Saudi Arabian health ministry statement said 4,000 people died in the Hajj stampede—then disappeared

Published September 30th, 2015 - 03:23 GMT
A statement on Saudi's ministry of health site Tuesday said 4,000 people were killed in the Hajj stampede. (AFP/File)
A statement on Saudi's ministry of health site Tuesday said 4,000 people were killed in the Hajj stampede. (AFP/File)

There's strange news coming — and being redacted — from the Saudi Arabian Ministry of Heath about the death toll of Saturday's Hajj stampede in Mina.

As the baffling fatality numbers have shown, this is the worst disaster to strike Hajj since 1990. But just how large those numbers are is a debate still raging days after the accident. 

The ministry's Arabic website said Tuesday some 4,000 people died in the crush. The announcement's since been wiped from the page, but not before people (including Al Bawaba) managed to capture a screen shot. See it below.


Here's the translation: 

The Saudi Deputy Minister of Health Mohamed Aldowale stated that the ministry handed over a photo album with photos of 4,173 pilgrims who passed away in Mena accident, and the process of Identifying the bodies has started.

He also added that the big number of death was due to heat, suffocation and stampede, according to the report by the Minister of Health.

The primary statistics indicated 769 deaths however our final numbers have increased to 4173 deaths after the ministry received several more bodies yesterday.

Despite all the rumors and news in the media, the ministry would like to reconfirm that this site  and its social media handles are the only reliable and formal sources for official statements.


With the official death count tallied by the Saudi government so far floating around 800, that's a miles-long discrepancy not lost on social media users. Here's what one said to Vice Minister of Heath Hamad al-Dhewalia's Twitter handle, with a screenshot of the ministry announcement attached.

Translation: Hamad al-Dhewalia, is this from the ministry website? The statement is attributed to you, and the site looks like the ministry's official one. and the site looks as the formal one.


Between this and US's foggy statements on the Syrian rebel train-and-equip program, what's going on with government pages this week?

© 2000 - 2023 Al Bawaba (www.albawaba.com)

You may also like


Sign up to our newsletter for exclusive updates and enhanced content